Oscar Cardenas
English 101, section 31
Ms. Nargiza Matyakubova
12/14/2018
Nature or Nurture: who is innocent and who is guilty?
Abstract:
This Paper will discuss the topic of nature vs nurture within the cause behind serial killers. Whatever if it a biological issue or is it a environmental issue for the creation of serial killers. Reason for this paper to help create a clear cut reason for serial killers and Methods to better understand these type of killers and what are some ways to help with the prevent of these type of people. The result show that there are evidence for both sides at the same time that environment plays a larger role.
Cardenas 1
“You feel the last bit of breath leaving their body. You’re looking into their eyes. A person in that situation is God!” This was said by a man who said himself to be one of the coldest-hearted people you will ever meet: Ted Bundy. People wonder what on earth makes a man like him a serial killer; many would even question his humanity. Ever since Ted Bundy’s case, there has been one question on everyone’s mind: what are the reasons for these types of killers? Are they genetically likely to become violent, or does their environment shape them to become violent? Are serial killers naturally evil or do they turn into people who commit such evil acts? Serial killers are created and molded by others around them and stopping the creation of more evil men like this needs start today. There are many known serial killers going from H.H Holmes to Ted Bundy and to Jeffrey Dahmer. Some believe that these killers are born with a certain gene in their genetic code that causes them to show traits of psychopathy and antisocial personality disorder, thus showing the potential of a future serial killer in the making. However, the nurture point of view is the idea that the world and it is this world that causes killers to become this way, molding them into evil. This idea, that a person’s surroundings influence his actions and behaviors, is the leading cause of serial killers.
First need to understand what is considered a serial killer and definition of a serial killer under the standards set by society. To be considered a serial killer you must first commit murders three or more people in a period of over a month, with cooling down time between murders the murders must be separate events, which are most often driven by a psychological
Cardenas 2
thrill or pleasure.There are three different type of serial killers, The first being the The Medical Killer which is a “people who have become involved in the medical industry as a way to carry out their nefarious deed”(Types of serial killers)Example of this is H.H Holmes with his studied medicine at a small school in Vermont before being accepted into the University of Michigan Medical School().Following this we go into the The Organized Killer This type of serial killer is the “most difficult to identify and capture. They are usually highly intelligent and well organized to the point of being meticulous”(Types of serial killers)examples of these type of killers is Ted Bundy as they plan every moment of the kill and how will they be able to capture the victim. Following this lastly is the The disorganized Killer These individuals “rarely plan out the deaths of their victims in any way. Most often, the people they kill just happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time” Jeffery dahmer is the idea type of killer with majority of his kills happening in the moment rather than plan(Types of serial killers).
The first American Serial killers were first documented in the 19th century had appeared. Dr. Henry Howard Holmes, more commonly known as H. H. Holmes, was an American serial killer, known for his creation of the “Murder Castle.” which he constructed to feel like a maze from within so that his victims may never escape. He constructed multiple torture chambers to use on his victims. He later confessed to 28 other murders upon his arrest; however, it is believe that Holmes is responsible for up to 200 murders. In May 1896 H.H. Holmes was hanged(Crime Museum)Since then, the number of serial killers has grown rapidly.
Some believe that these killers are born with a certain gene in their genetic code that causes them to show traits of psychopathy and antisocial personality disorder, thus showing the
Cardenas 3
potential of a future serial killer in the making that is passed down through family lines which causes this. Some claim that a serial killer’s brain is different from those of others. According to
Fallon (2013) an American neuroscientist , “All of these areas of loss make up the major chunk of brain called the limbic, or emotional, cortex, since this is the main area regulating emotion” (pp. 59). Fallon argues serial killer brains are struct differently from normal brains and this is leading cause for why they are so violent and feel no remorse toward their victim once commit the crime of murder. Contradicting this is research done by Ruth Burthman, who stated“Yes, brains of serial killers look different, but it does not follow that their brains looked different at birth. This has yet to be seen. Instead, current brain research suggests that our brains change throughout our life span, for better and for worse.” The biology behind the brian shows that the structure of the human brain changes for everyone no matter what everyone brains changes thus contradicting Fallon’s perspective on the issue. Thus helping support the idea that serial killers are created rather from nurture and what they grow up around.
Many psychologists and criminologists have looked for answers and believe the answer goes all the way back to birth. The majority of serial killers develop violent tendencies during the early stages of their childhood, with certain environmental factors that has been common
Cardenas 4
between all serial killers according to Laurence Miller, “Many were severely abused physically and sexually as children” along with:
The individual is often a loner, although many are married or live in relatively stable relationships. He often appears to others as intelligent and charming. He may be stably housed and employed or he may change jobs and residential locales frequently(p.p 1-2,12-13).
As children, they lose their feeling of control or self respect in their lives. This tendency is evident in the infamous serial killer Ted Bundy. During his trial, Bundy explains the feeling of being a “god” which shows the idea of wanting that sense of control back in his life. John Philip Jenkins explains the type of environment Bundy was living in: “childhood; he had a strained relationship with his stepfather, and his shyness made him a frequent target of bullying”( Jenkins, 2018). Bundy never had that feeling of control in his life and wanted get that feeling back by taking another person’s life; therefore, he was created by his environment of facing bullying and not being able have control of his life because of his father. Because of all this Bundy would go to the lengths of having full control of the situation, Plan every moment he would:
“often wearing his arm in a sling or his leg in a fake cast and walking on crutches. He would then use his charm and faked disability to convince his victims to help him carry books or unload objects from his car”(Ted Bundy)
A question that should also be asked is, what is it like growing up to become a serial killer? The book Jack Olsen I: the creation of a serial killer provides the point of view of serial
Cardenas 5
killers while they are growing up. Readers with us following the life of in the book I: the creation of a serial killer by Jack Olsen we follow to the point of Keith Jesperson and in one time the family could tell her was not a normal kid from the start with his father giving the idea of
“We always knew he was different,” Keith Jesperson’s father admits, “but we never thought he would kill.”Olsen, Jack (p. 33). The idea that a father knew something wrong with his kid but doesn't want to admit it shows a issue that needs fixing. It can take one moment or many certain types of events to push them down this road.
As said it just takes one bad day to turn into that. Criminologist give an example by using Jeffrey Dahmer, one of the most known serial killers, and his childhood. (Serial Killers: Nature vs. Nurture) claims that “you will find that at an early age he was a fun and active child who his father described as, "Very exuberant, he liked to wrestle, liked to run around, ham it up for the camera and he liked to play with kids and get together with them" (Serial Killers: Nature vs. Nurture). The author continues to say how soon later the family began to move around a lot, thus leading Dahmer to feel like a outcast; Later, he “began collecting roadkill and dissecting it in experiments.” the idea here’s a man who when a kid did not show the natural signs of psychopath and future serial killers in the making. However he was changed into this with the issues of moving around a lot never really gave him a place to feel at home and always a loner. He lashed out and looked for ways to get away and just feel normal again. During Jeffrey Dahmer interview in 1993 with the news inside edition he explains his state of mine and how the all he wanted to do was keep his victim with him and have them under his control because it
Cardenas 6
relates back to his childhood with his parents divorce and the feeling of being alone and wanting change that feeling by making sure these people never leave him and he felt the only way to do.this was to kill them and that would allow him to have them completely stay with him.
An interview asking Dr. Stone questions such as whether or not serial killers are born evil. He goes on stating how we have certain areas within our brains that control our sexual desires
which are part of the limbic system that connects to the frontal lobe and if this is damage by a head injury as a child this can cause change within the person and ultimately could lead to thoughts and fansty of committing certain crimes. He gives examples that 30% of serial killer have had a brain injury during their childhood. However he states that their environment plays as a motive for why they kill.Along with how they pick their victims and why they kill who they kill. Following this, more facts on sources such as Nature vs Nurture: The Role of Childhood
Abuse in Making a Murderer By The Forensic Outreach Team Criminal Minds
a father plays a larger role in a child’s life with:
“cases where a cruel and harsh dad
is a sort of looming, domineering figure. Usually, these men are iron-fisted and sadistic
disciplinarians. The misconception that this discipline will ‘toughen’ a child is often to blame.
Instead, this usually results in a lack of love, and means that the child lacks a basic sense of
compassion and empathy. Furthermore, this abuse often feeds later fantasies of domination and
control.”
Cardenas 7
The idea of how a parent needs to be in order to raise a child according to the social and cultural standards that are set can cause negative effects on people’s personality thus causing damage on a person’s mental state, and in the future causes to lash out towards others as a result.
Solution in effect to prevent the creation of more serial killers is steps that can be taken is one acknowledging the early signs of a serial killer and being able to get the help that they need.
Some of the early signs on tell if a child in in danger of becoming a potential serial killer are antisocial behavior Psychopaths have a strong tendency towards antisocial behavior, so watch for extremely antisocial children as if so get them the help they need to help support this behavior. Following this Arson any serial killers start as arsonists,”Arson is psychologically attractive because it involves manipulating power and control, something that serial killing also offers”(Frese, S). Another clear warning sign is the killing of animals “Children who torture or kill small animals like squirrels, birds, cats, and dogs without showing remorse are highly likely to be sociopaths. Many serial killers kill to control others’ lives, and as children, small animals are the only lives they have the power to control”(Frese, S). Childhood Abuse many serial killers are abused – physically, psychologically, sexually as children by a close family member typically creating this need to feel a sense of control again and power(Frese, S). Poor Family Life,many serial killers come from unstable families with criminal, psychiatric, or alcoholic histories.Thus leading to have bad relationships with their family member creating no attachment toward any people. Ways to fix this issues is for social service to pay more close attention and
Cardenas 8
help get word out to prevent the abuse of a child and get the help they need and help important family life overall. Many serial killers struggle with drug and alcohol abuse,Jeffrey Dahmer began drinking in his teens and was an alcoholic by his high school graduation due to the lack of stress he face in his unhappy household(Frese, S).Finally Voyeurism which serial killers “From a young age, many serial killers are interested in voyeurism, sado-masochistic pornography, and fetishism”(Frese, S) With these type of fansty playing within the head of a youth the question isn’t will he or she ever commit these fantasy but rather when will they give into the fantasy and play them out.
To conclude that the need for this research more of the facts of need help create system and rehab for these youth. Not only to help them and for the future but also protect future lives and the changing of more lives rather than themselves as people. To improve the social standards that they are living in and fight against this type of evil that is living in our world.
Citation data
Aggression and Violent Behavior,2014,01,I. Subtypes, patterns, and motive
http://www.nc-cm.org/article213.htm,Serial Killers: Nature vs. Nurture,October 20, 2018
The Forensic Outreach Library,Nature vs Nurture: The Role of Childhood Abuse in Making a Murderer,February 20, 2018,October 20, 2018
I: the creation of a serial killer,St. Martins Paperbacks,Year 2003
The New York Times,Sympathetic Serial Killers,June 24, 2011,October 20, 2018
REFERENCE ENTRY,Bundy, Ted,,John Philip Jenkins,Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc,2018
The psychopath inside : a neuroscientist's personal journey into the dark side of the brain,2013,Fallon, James H
H.H. Holmes. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.crimemuseum.org/crime-library/serial-killers/hh-holmes/
Edition, I. (2018, November 27). Inside the Mind of Jeffrey Dahmer: Serial Killer's Chilling Jailhouse Interview. Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWjYsxaBjBI
Types Of Serial Killers. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.crimemuseum.org/crime-library/serial-killers/types-of-serial-killers/
Frese, S. (2014, June 23). - Crime and Forensic Blog. Retrieved from https://www.crimemuseum.org/2014/06/23/9-early-warning-signs-for-serial-killers-2/
Think, B. (2011, June 10). Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89FjS6SRESY
Comments
Post a Comment